by Max Brantley
Despite its generally low profile, ALEC has drawn scrutiny recently for promoting gun rights policies like the Stand Your Ground law at the center of the Trayvon Martin shooting case in Florida, as well as bills to weaken labor unions and tighten voter identification rules. Amid the controversies, several companies, including Coca-Cola, Intuit and Kraft Foods, have left the group.
Most of the attention has focused on ALEC’s role in creating model bills, drafted by lobbyists and lawmakers, that broadly advance a pro-business, socially conservative agenda. But a review of internal ALEC documents shows that this is only one facet of a sophisticated operation for shaping public policy at a state-by-state level. The records offer a glimpse of how special interests effectively turn ALEC’s lawmaker members into stealth lobbyists, providing them with talking points, signaling how they should vote and collaborating on bills affecting hundreds of issues like school vouchers and tobacco taxes.
In Arkansas, of course, ALEC has moved beyond merely providing stealth talking points, though it does a lot of that, along with the Koch brothers' corporate lobby Americans for Prosperity. It has even appeared to testify for its agenda bills introduced by adherents, such as Sen. Missy Irvin's bill to kill expanded health care for the U.S. and Rep. Ed Garner's bill to give the wealthy an enormous tax break.
The article notes that, despite state legislators claim to the contrary, the corporate backers who underwrite most of the cost (allowing legislators to be members for a nominal $50) often exercise veto power over legislation.
ALEC-influenced legislators introduce 1,000 pieces of legislation a year and pass about 17 percent.
A members-only newsletter from 1995, found in an online archive of tobacco company documents, bluntly characterized that success ratio as “a good investment.”
“Nowhere else can you get a return that high,” it said
ALEC is a nonprofit 501C3 public charity, meaning the companies that pay for it can get a tax deduction for the expense. Thus, American taxpayers are subsidizing the cost of the conservative corporate lobby influence on their state legislators.
UPDATE: Common Cause plans a news conference Monday at which it apparently will seek an IRS review of ALEC's activities. There are limits on political activites by tax-exempt nonprofits. Common Cause claims to have documents to shed further light on ALEC's practices.
Who: Common Cause President Bob Edgar; Whistleblower Attorney Eric R. Havian
What: Common Cause will announce new evidence involving the activities and inner workings of the American Legislative Exchange Council, or ALEC, a secretive, corporate-backed front group through which corporate leaders join with state legislators to write – and then pass in state houses from coast to coast — “model” bills that benefit corporations, often at the expense of American taxpayers.
When: Monday, April 23 at noon ET
Join: Dial (877)317-2314, and ask for conference ID# 74236016
In the wake of the Trayvon Martin shooting in Florida, and ALEC’s connection to the “Stand Your Ground” gun law that for weeks protected the teen-ager’s killer, ALEC has been under intense media and public scrutiny. At least 11 major corporations, including McDonald’s, Wendy’s, Coca Cola and PepsiCo, have announced their departure from ALEC. Common Cause will announce a whistleblower complaint it filed with the IRS against ALEC based on a large trove of ALEC records obtained by Common Cause. The documents raise new questions, including legal issues, about ALEC’s activities.