by Max Brantley
The Distilled Spirits Council today signaled disappointment that Governor Asa Hutchinson signed SB 284 into law, which moves wine into grocery stores and devastates local, Arkansas package stores.The spirits lobby never counted for much in this debate. More interesting now is whether the pushback from retail liquor stores, through several bills to improve their competitive position, will get any traction in the remainder of the session. What if, for example, grocery stores had to abide by the church/school distance rules that liquor stores have to follow to expand their wine sales? Or what about chaining? Or what about competition in the wholesale department? Let a thousand bottles bloom.
“Instead of picking winners and losers, Arkansas should implement a plan that is consumer-friendly and provides a level playing field for beer, wine and spirits,” said Distilled Spirits Council Vice President Dale Szyndrowski. “We urge Governor Hutchinson and the Arkansas legislature to come back to the table and help retailers that were left out of this deal. We believe there is a fair approach to reforming Arkansas’ outdated alcohol laws that serves all parties.”
SB 284 would allow wine purchases in grocery stores, while spirits sales would remain segregated to package stores. According to an economic analysis, existing package stores are projected to lose an average of $90,000 in revenue annually, or about eight percent of store revenue. As a result, an estimated 35-40 stores would go out of business, costing 100-150 workers their jobs.
“Stakeholders came together in Colorado last year to craft legislation that allowed grocers to purchase the package store licenses of retailers within close proximity to grocery stores, thus not denying consumers access to beer, wine and spirits, while also protecting the value of the existing package stores. We urge Arkansas lawmakers to look to that model legislation in order to strike a compromise that benefits every stakeholder,” Szyndrowski concluded.